April Tax Showers are a Drought, the Facebook "Bump" is About to Fizzle, What's So Merry About the Month of May? by Sheila Kuehl August 11, 2012 This is the fifth in a series of essays exploring California's 2012-13 budget. The first essay explained the general provisions of the Governor's January budget. The second discussed specific cuts proposed to welfare-to-work (CalWORKS), child care and Medi-Cal. The third analyzed the January proposals related to K-14 and higher education. The fourth revealed the details of proposed realignment funding, and proposed "government efficiencies". Leaving behind the Governor's proposed January budget, this essay moves on to the significant changes made in the revised May budget regarding the general financial picture, the new plunging deficit and education, 0-16. The next essay will continue the explanation of the "May Revise", concentrating on social services and prisons. Further essays will explain changes contained in the June legislative budget, the final June budget sent to the Governor, his"blue-pencil" vetoes, and a dash of inside information on the process. Spring: The Time for Philosophy is Over Perhaps the ancient cyclical rhythm of each natural passing year dictates our moods and actions even when our feet are firmly planted on cement. Perhaps our very genes contain some race memory that draws us to the seasonal nature of ancient gardens we no longer really remember. Is that why we seem to harbor a continual hope for the saving graces of the merriest month of May? Each year the Legislature looks to the "May Revise", the new budget proposal from the Governor that follows the "cruelest" month of tax collection (with apologies to T.S. Eliot), with a strange hope that May will bring a miraculous rebirth. Instead, as Peter Loewer, the renowned gardening guru, wrote, "In May, the discussion of philosophy is over--it's time for the work to begin." More than the seasons were changing, however. In a major break with historical budget negotiations between the two Houses, it was decided that there would be no Conference Committee, which, in the past, had been comprised of an equal number of members from the Assembly and the Senate, tasked with reconciling, in a series of public hearings, the differences between the two houses' versions of the budget. Whatever agreements the two Democratic leaders and the Governor reached would dictate the budget sent back to the houses for an up or down vote. It was, therefore, expected, that the Speaker of the Assembly and the President pro Tempore of the Senate would meet to wrestle out the differences, with no public hearings. Instead, the budget Chair and five budget sub-committee chairs from the Assembly met with President pro Temps Steinberg to work out agreements in each of their areas. Those a bit removed from the action might think this a democratic and generous move. However, it is much more difficult for a chair or sub-chair from the Assembly to strike individual and complicated deals with the head of the Senate and hold the Senate to it later, as will be seen in June. When Pruning Shears Are Your Only Gardening Tool In January the estimated General Fund "shortfall" was 10.3 billion dollars, including a 1.1 billion dollar reserve. In the May Revise, that deficit had grown to 16.7 billion. And this didn't include the upcoming Facebook IPO disappointment which, at the time of the May Revise, was slated to add a whopping 1.5 billion dollars to revenues. The reasons for the fattened deficit: $3 billion less in tax revenue in April than expected, 2.4 billion in higher costs to fund the schools as property taxes continue to plummet, and federal court decisions holding that California could not extract a co-pay from Medi-Cal recipients, adding 1.7 billion to expenditures, nor could they cut Medi-Cal provider rates. In addition, the federal court-appointed Receiver over medical care in the prisons required even more money. As a start on solving the deficit, the Governor proposed 8.3 billion in cuts and savings from reduced caseloads in Cal-Works and Medi-Cal (from new tighter income eligibility standards). He included 1.2 billion in additional revenue expected from his November tax initiative. The Governor had agreed to merge his original proposal with the so-called "millionaire's tax" proposal from CSEA and the Courage Campaign and others. The revenue expectation, should the measure pass in November, was increased to 8.5 billion (which would require an additional 2.9 billion in Prop 98 expenditures, and 5.6 billion going into the general fund). Killing the Orchard to Save the Fruit Higher education received another round of cuts. The UC system, which was to have received an augmentation of 90 million for base operations to fund retirement contributions is reduced in the May Revise by 38 million. The "trigger" amount--the additional monies the UC system will lose should the November tax measure fail is increased from 200 to 250 million. The May Revise also revealed that the Governor had changed his mind about not funding annual budget adjustments for retirement at CSU, and adds 52 million to their budget. However, it all becomes ephemeral if the "trigger" kicks in so that CSU, like UC, would have 250 million in additional cuts. For the whole California Community College system, the May Revise continues to combine a plethora of separate mandates placed on the colleges (and K-12) into a huge flexible block grant. However, the payment scheme is changed in the May Revise so that per-pupil block grant allocations in both the community colleges and in K-12 (which had, traditionally, had different per-pupil allocations for the mandates) would be $28 per student, across the board. The revisions also did away with a few more mandates, including the Discrimination Complaint Procedures mandate. The end of redevelopment as we have known it continues to resonate throughout the budget. In the 2011-12 budget, the May Revise gives an additional 30.8 million to the Community Colleges to fill a decrease in estimated local property tax revenues. For 2012-13, however, the CC budget is decreased because of an expected recovery of cash assets held by redevelopment agencies. The Community Colleges also see a larger loss, if the "trigger" is pulled after the election--from 292 million to 325 million. The Shrubs Don't Do So Well, Either Although the May Revise funds Prop 98 at the minimum level of 53.7 billion representing an increase in the minimum guarantee of 1.2 billion over the January budget, the full funding continues to be based on passage of the tax initiative. Still, it would provide a year-to-year increase of 5.9 billion over the revised 2011-12 spending level. If the tax initiative does not pass, the trigger cuts would render the K-12 budget 700 million less than proposed in the January budget. Revenue expectations include 981 million from tax-increment redevelopment funds which will now go to schools. This amount, as well as disposition of the liquid assets of the redevelopment agencies across the state, is up for argument, of course, as the cities fight to keep their money and their projects. In one bright note, school transportation funding, which had been eliminated in the January budget, is restored. But Those Who Nurture the Shoots Fight Back Having hit an angry swarm of bees, not to mention a brick wall, in the budget sub-committees, especially in the Assembly, the Governor backtracked on his January proposal of a 10% reduction in the state reimbursement rate for providers. Instead, the new budget directs an estimated 92 million dollars in prop 98 savings, theoretically generated by not funding the Transitional Kindergarten program, and transfers it to the part-day state preschool program, restoring about 34 million. The May Revise also proposes an increase of 58 million for an additional 15,500 preschool slots. In the non-prop 98 child care part of the budget (CalWORKS child care for working parents receiving benefits), the Governor, fending off angry push-back from women members of the Legislature, rescinded his January proposal that would have required all child care subsidy recipients to meet federal work participation requirements, which are slightly more stringent than California's (they all still have to work). Under the January proposal, thousands of families currently engaged in educating themselves to get a job or working in somewhat subsidized jobs would have been dropped and their children suddenly left with no care. Instead, the governor restored the education and subsidized job option but paid for it with an even greater reduction to the reimbursement rates paid for child care vouchers. Translation: You may be theoretically entitled to child care while you're studying or working, but, as with Medi-Cal, there will be fewer providers on the list. Finally, the Governor, again responding to major pushback from the Assembly budget sub-committee, abandoned his idea of pushing all child care into the welfare system. Instead, he added a few protections, including creating a separate block grant program (so the counties can't just gobble up the money), keeping the current number of slots in Title V programs, and leaving Child Care Development Block Grants to be overseen by the Department of Education, not the Department of Social Services. This will be an ongoing fight, so stay tuned. Next: Health and Social Services and Prisons in the May Revise |
