July 12, 2012 Gov. Brown's January Budget: The Tin Man Strikes Again by Sheila Kuehl This is the first in a series of new essays chronologically setting out the twists and turns of the 2012-13 California budget from its introduction by the Governor in January of this year, to the "May Revise" that changes everything after the April 15th money rolls in (or doesn't) to the final June budget to the Governor's vetoes. Along the way, I'll identify the winners and losers, the more-closed-than-ever process and the impacts on poor, reeling California. This essay sets out the major pieces of the January budget, as the Governor sent it to the Legislature. The next essay will focus on the January proposal's specific impacts on social services, child care and the safety net, among others. The Tin Man and His Tin Scissors Most people don't know that L. Frank Baum, who wrote the Wizard of Oz books, was a populist with a passion for true American equality. Thanks to the MGM movie starring Judy Garland, most of Baum's political overlay is lost to the general public, but, in truth, he fashioned the Tin Man to stand for industrialization, which didn't have a heart, while the Scarecrow stood for the farmer, who looked to be wiped out by industrialization. The saving factor, Baum thought, would be for the workers in industrialized cities (the tin men) to develop their hearts and make league with the farmers for the good of all. Unfortunately, the latest California budget shows that our Governor remains, as the Tin Man described his chest sans heart, "an empty kettle"---as heartlessly unconcerned as ever about the poor, whether they've lost their farms or their industrial jobs. For the ninth time, in as many years, the state budget is balanced by imposing deep cuts to the social services safety net and hanging a sword of Damocles over public education until the November election. It All Begins in January In January, as he does in the first month of every year, the Governor sent his first formal draft of the proposed 2012-13 budget to the Legislature. The budget presentation began with what the Dept of Finance calls "the overall budget problem". This is budget-speak for a projected shortfall of revenue to expense of about 9.2 billion dollars by the end of June 2013, if no changes were made to the framework of the 2011-12 budget. 4.1 billion of the projected shortfall would stem from an imbalance in the 2011-12 budget and the rest would be caused by the lopsided budget structure in 2012-13. In order to solve the problem and present a balanced budget, the Governor proposed to make an additional 10.3 billion in cuts: 9.2 to solve the "problem" of the imbalance and 1.1 billion extra to build a reserve. These changes would mean that total expenditures for the current budget year (2011-12) would be held to 86.5 billion, and the 2012-13 budget expenditures would total 92.6 billion. The greater expenditure figure for 2012-13 was to be met through passage of the Governor's tax measure on the November ballot (about 4 billion) and from the repayment of Prop 1A bonds issued under Schwarzenegger to repay local governments for borrowing property tax money to balance the 2009-10 budget (2 billion). "You must pay the rent.... but i can't pay the rent" Every time I write one of these pieces detailing, yet again, the devastating cuts to California's social services safety net, I think of the heroines of the silent movies facing the heartless landlord, or the heroine tied to the tracks as the train approaches. Except, for years, there's been no last-minute rescue, and this 2012-13 budget is no exception. The Governor decided to leave the K-12 public education system untouched in the budget, so long as his tax measure passes in November. However, even if the tax measure passes, it would not provide any new money for the safety net. In other words, you can go to school, kid, but don't expect food in the house, child care for your younger sibs, help for grandma, medical attention or new shoes. A Different California: Those Who Have and Have Not The cuts proposed by the Governor in January, to be fair, must have seemed like the only way available to balance the budget. As can be seen in the next section, most revenue solutions were taken off the table by the Republican caucuses in the Legislature. Consequently, the budget proposed a further reduction in CalWORKS (California's welfare to work program) of almost a billion dollars, including, as I'll lay out in my second essay, a significant "redesign" of the program. An additional 842 million dollars was taken out of the state's MediCal (California's Federal Medicaid and state match program), primarily by enrolling more seniors and disabled recipients in managed care plans. Despite the fact that deep cuts have been made in several past years to these same programs, the Governor proposed 163 million in further cuts to In-Home Support Services for the elderly and disabled, another 544 million out of public school and community college districts, mostly by tinkering with the Prop 98 guarantee (with money flowing back in to education only if the tax measure passes), 447 million more slashed from already-reeling child care programs, 301 million cut from the Cal-Grant program and 823 million carved from "reforms" in the payments to local governments for things the state requires them to fund. Revenues, To Do and Not To Do First: what was not done to bring in more money. The tax giveaway to the eight or ten largest corporations doing business in California continued (about 6 billion overall) as there was no 2/3 vote to end it. Of course, when the people of California were given a chance to end that tax giveaway in 2010, they voted not to do it! They preferred, apparently, to keep supporting the corporations and cutting the schools. Never mind that I can't find one voter that said, "Yes, of course I meant to do that!" What they usually say is, "Huh? That's what that Proposition was about?" Nor was an oil extraction tax imposed on the oil companies such as that imposed by every other oil-producing state in the country. Nor was there even a courtesy vote to put the Governor's tax measure out for a vote. Consequently, Brown negotiated with the organizations backing the so-called "millionaires tax" and came up with a compromise that went out for signatures and will, indeed, be on the ballot in November. That measure, charmingly dubbed the Temporary Personal Income Tax Rates on Highest Income Californians is projected in the January budget (fingers crossed) to reap 5.8 billion by adding three additional tax brackets for earners grossing 250,000 or more (500 for couples), with the highest rate imposed on earners of 500,000 or more (a million for joint filers). In addition, the Governor proposed continuation of an add-on (though by being allowed to expire this year, it had to be called a rise) in sales taxes of .5 percent, for a proposed gain of 1.2 billion. The Precarious Winners Should the additional taxes pass, the money will go to prevent deeper cuts to the schools, protect local public safety funding, and invest a little more in higher education. However, because the vote is not until November, the budget, as proposed in January, also contained a "trigger" that would impose 5.4 billion in additional cuts, primarily to public education and public safety, should the measure fail. These cuts would include almost 5 billion in cuts to K-12 education, 400 million more in cuts to higher ed, 125 million more in cuts to the courts, 6 million more in cuts to Fish and Game and 7 million in cuts to the flood control programs. Next: A closer look at the Governor's January proposals for cuts to child care, social services and the safety net. |
