SheilaKuehl.org

Sheila's Writings

Welcome‎ > ‎

2012-13 Budget Essay No. 7: Of Cabbages and Kings, the June Legislative Budget

by Sheila Kuehl
August 23, 2012

This is the seventh in a series of essays exploring California's 2012-13 budget. It presents the budget sent on June 15th from the Legislature to the Governor, still lacking his agreement on several large issues.   

The first essay in this series explained the general provisions of the Governor's January budget. The second discussed specific cuts proposed to welfare-to-work (CalWORKS), child care and Medi-Cal.  The third analyzed the January proposals related to K-14 and higher education.  The fourth revealed the details of proposed realignment funding, and proposed "government efficiencies".  The fifth set forth the revised May budget concerning the general financial picture, the new plunging deficit and education, 0-16.  The sixth presented May revisions in Social Services and Prisons.

Further essays will present the changes made in the final June budget, the Governor's "blue-pencil" vetoes, and a dash of information on the process.    

In Lewis Carroll's epic story, Alice Through the Looking Glass,

 
Tweedledum and Tweedledee, hands folded prettily for a recitation, intone a nonsense poem to Alice, in which the Walrus and the Carpenter take a leisurely stroll on the beach, deep in conversation. With an eye toward their next meal, they invite a group of unsuspecting young oysters to join them, promising a deep and philosophical discourse...
 
"The time has come," the Walrus said,
"To talk of many things:
Of shoes--and ships--and sealing-wax-
Of cabbages--and kings
..."
 
Fascinated by the attention, the young and naive oysters are eaten, one by one, having morphed from discourse to main course.
 
Alice is then asked by the odd twins which of the two characters she liked best.
"I like the Walrus best," said Alice, "because you see he was a little sorry for the poor oysters."
"He ate more than the Carpenter, though," said Tweedledee. "You see he held his handkerchief in front, so that the Carpenter couldn't count how many he took: contrariwise."
"That was mean!" Alice said indignantly. "Then I like the Carpenter best--if he didn't eat so many as the Walrus."
"But he ate as many as he could get," said Tweedledum.
This was a puzzler. After a pause, Alice began, "Well! They were both very unpleasant characters."
 
The Legislature Trims the Cabbage and Floats a Budget Down to the King
 
The mid-June budget dance turned out, indeed, to be about cabbages and kings, and agreement by the two majority legislative leaders on which little oysters would not survive the year. The Speaker, interestingly, seems to have devolved negotiations with the President pro-Temps down to his budget sub-chairs.  Still, he insisted that all Democrats vote out the resulting budget and down it went to the Governor.  For his part, the Governor had not yet agreed to any of the changes made to his May Revision budget, but the Legislature was in a hurry-up mood.
 
The voters had approved an initiative in 2010 allowing a budget to pass on a simple majority vote in the Legislature  (though still retaining the 2/3 requirement to raise a tax).  Perhaps more importantly, the initiative stripped legislators of their pay should they fail to put a balanced budget on the Governor's desk in time.
 
Voila!  On June 15th, the Legislature voted out a balanced budget loved by them alone (and then not very much) and sent it from the third floor to the first floor of the Capitol in the nick of time, even without the assenting nod of the King. The Legislative-only budget had greatly reduced total cabbage to match revenues, but had bucked the King by restoring some of the cuts made in his May Revise. It was still pretty brutal. In the eyes of the little oysters about to be gobbled, the Walrus, the Carpenter and the King were all very unpleasant characters.
 
Still, the Legislature did its best to preserve some programs and protections for the poorest in our state. Though their budget diverged from the May Revision by less than one percent, it managed to restore some social programs, partly by leaving a year-end reserve of only half a billion rather than the full billion proposed by the Governor.  For the most part, the May Revise was adopted.  However, along with some agreements, there were a few major differences, as seen below.
 
Health
 
The Legislative budget ratified the Governor's proposal to impose co-payments in Medi-Cal and approved a modified version of the proposal to integrate Medi-Cal and Medicare services as well as the integration of long-term care services, including In-Home Supportive Services and nursing home care, into managed care. However, the budget reduced funding to hospitals by almost 400 million, and denied the Governor's proposal to reform payment systems for Federally Qualified Health Centers and Rural Health Centers.
 
Importantly, in a sweeping rebuff, the Legislature refused to reduce provider rates in the Healthy Families Program down to the level of Medi-Cal rates and also refused to transfer all the children in the program to Medi-Cal.  The Legislative budget limited that transfer, instead, to children whose family income is below 133 percent of the federal poverty level, as required by the ACA. They also required that children moving into Medi-Cal continue to receive dental services, which is one of many coverage differences between Healthy Families and Medi-Cal.
 
For participants in the AIDS Drug Assistance Program, the Legislature denied the Governor's proposal to increase cost sharing, which had been calculated to shift 10.7 million dollars of costs to clients.
 
Human Services
 
The Legislature did not agree with the Governor on taking almost 900 million dollars out of the CalWORKS welfare-to-work program.  The May Revise scored the savings by greatly limiting access to CalWORKS, reducing the time a family was allowed to be on aid and severely reducing child-only payments, as described in my last essay.
 
They also rejected the Governor's proposal to cut 7% from In-Home Supportive Services, choosing rather to continue an already-existing 3.6 % reduction, and tapping federal funds for the difference.
 
Education
 
Most of the Governor's May proposals for education were adopted, but some proposed reductions were rejected. Trailer bill language was proposed to authorize K-12 schools to cut the length of the school year to 160 days in 2012-13 and 2013-14, in essence, giving them an option to reduce the school year by up to 15 days.
 
However, the Legislature rejected the Governor's proposal doing away with Transitional Kindergarten, as well as his proposal for a weighted pupil formula. They restored 15 million dollars in Prop 98 funding for the Early Mental Health Initiative (but shifted the program to the Dept. of Education), as well as for a number of programs the May Revise had reduced or ended. Funding was proposed, instead, by utilizing federal funds and some one-time funding.
 
Higher Education
 
A number of proposals in the Governor's January budget were rejected, restoring current law concerning state prioritized programs, current year funding levels, and enrollment targets.
 
For the Community Colleges, the Legislature denied the Governor's proposal to consolidate 411 million from 21 categorical programs into one big block grant and earmarked all 21 categoricals at current level. The Legislature also denied May Revise proposals to align Cal Grant awards with federal Pell Grants, to eliminate students from eligibility for Cal Grants by raising GPA eligibility requirements and to phase out the student loan assumption program.
 
Child Care
 
In one of the most dramatic refusals, the Legislature denied the Governor's January proposal to "realign" the administration of child care and developmental services from the Department of Education to the Department of Social Services.  Placing all child care programs under the control of counties and putting them within welfare services was considered a tectonic change from the emphasis on early childhood education, statewide eligibility and oversite.  They also denied the proposed consolidation of child care programs into a separate child care block grant fund.
 
The Legislature's June 15th budget also reinstated standard child care reimbursement rates to current levels, denying the Governor's proposal to reduce both the General Child Care Program and the California State Preschool Program by 10%. They also denied the proposal in the May Revise which would have reduced reimbursement market rates by about 35%.
 
Further stating a different vision for the funding and provision of child care, the legislative budget rejected the Governor's proposed cap of two years of child care services for those participating in education programs and denied the reduction of state median income eligibility.  Overall, the Legislature seemed not to like the evisceration of child care proposed by the Governor, but did allow an across-the board reduction to General Fund supported child care.
 
And, Again, The Courts and Juvenile Justice
 
The Legislature, in restoring many of the cuts proposed in the May Revise, still had to come up with a balanced budget, and, thus, made even more cuts to courts, counties and state workers. The elimination of the Division of Juvenile Justice, as proposed in the May Revise, was withdrawn and, instead, the June 15th budget proposed to increase the base fee charged to the counties for incarcerating serious juvenile offenders.  In addition, the budget proposed discharging certain parolees in the juvenile system a year earlier than is now the case.  A proposal to diminish jurisdiction over juveniles from 25 years old to 23 years old was adopted.
 
The King is Not Amused
 
The major sticking points remained those related to welfare cuts and child care, among others. Even though the Legislature sent a full budget bill to Governor Brown, they did not send the bulk of more than two dozen "trailer" bills that are needed to carry out the programs. It is in the trailer bills that actual statutory details are set forth and, until the Governor and the two Democratic legislative leaders finally came to agreement, the budget was still in the nether land of negotiation.
 
Next: The Final Budget, Adopted and Trailered, but not yet Blue-Penciled

Comments